Wood vs. Steel Garage Doors — Is One Better Than the Other?

wood vs steel garage doors
CHI Overhead Doors wood garage door

Both wood and steel garage doors provide homeowners with an elegant and luxurious appeal that takes their surrounding exteriors to a whole new level.

But while these doors are great options, they are also very different from each other in terms of texture, look, and feel. So which door is right for you, and how can a homeowner decide between wood and steel? Fawley Overhead Door will break down the perks of each door to give you a greater insight into the option that best fits your desired garage aesthetic.

Wood Garage Doors

CHI Overhead Doors wood garage door

The first contestant in this “garage door materials showdown” takes center stage as one of the most natural and beautiful options for homeowners. Wood garage door options give a rustic feel while mixing in modern elements that create an aesthetic unique to your home. Today’s wood garage doors are long-lasting and invest-viable options, allowing homeowners to remake the entire feel of their home with supreme return value. 

Steel Garage Doors

You can customize these doors in carriage-style, louver, and raised panel or long panel designs for a fascinating look that complements your home and adds to the curb appeal. Steel garage doors are perfect for homeowners searching for an option with little to no maintenance requirements. On the other side of which garage door material is more charming or worthwhile, steel is the most popular choice!

What Are the Pros of a Wood Garage Door?

Why should you choose a wood garage door? Wood doors pop, giving eyes an immediate attraction. Anyone passing by your home will notice the beauty of your wood garage doors, and there aren’t many other options on the market with the creativity of wood doors. We’ll explore some more wood garage door pros below.

It Starts With the Appearance

There’s something timeless about a well-designed wood garage door. Other materials can’t compete with the natural elegance and beauty wood garage doors provide, making it a fascinating option for homeowners looking to stand out from the crowd.

Longevity and Durability

Wood garage doors don’t just stop at appearance, as wood naturally comes with a sturdy frame and strong panels. Best of all, wood doors repel scratches easily, and damaged panels can be easily replaced without tearing apart the entire door.

Energy Efficiency

If you’re active in the garage, the last thing you want is for your HVAC system to work extra hard to keep things warm or cool. Fortunately, wood doors naturally come with several layers of insulation, providing protection against the roughest exterior temperatures.

What Are the Pros of a Steel Garage Door?

As one of the most affordable and dependable materials on the market, steel garage doors are a unique look that ensures safety for your garage. There’s a reason homeowners are turning to steel more often than not, so let’s dive into more of the benefits of this garage door material. 


By far the most durable and affordable type of garage door, steel doors drastically reduce those garage door repair calls. Steel garage doors won’t easily warp, blister, or peel, and they require extremely heavy forces to make a dent in the door, especially with the addition of energy-saving insulation! 

Most steel garage doors are also outfitted with a polyester coating on the outside to keep away rust and corrosion. If you’re thinking about purchasing a steel garage door, homeowners can rest easy knowing they’re getting the most dependable door possible.

Safety and Security

With that strength comes safety and security. The primary purpose of a garage door is to protect your property, and steel garage doors are by far the best option for both structural integrity. There’s a reason commercial locations entrust steel materials to house their appliances. Steel is a highly functional material that prevents break-ins and adapts to demanding environments all while improving the curb appeal of your property.

Top-Tier Insulation

Steel garage doors require little maintenance while also providing insulation that lasts a lifetime. Garage doors are the main entryway into your home, so why not make sure they provide the best protection? 

Because insulated steel doors are so thick, fluctuating temperatures have little chance of affecting your home. This allows homeowners to use their garages in various ways, from home offices to spaces to work on their cars. Make your choice of single, double, or triple layers of insulation, and reap the benefits that garage door insulation offers!

Why Not Meet In The Middle? Consider Faux Wood Garage Doors

The benefits of steel garage doors versus wood garage doors are pretty great, so it’s no question that choosing between one over the other is a tough battle. What if a friendly mix of affordable steel garage doors and the desired aesthetic of wood garage doors came together to settle this debate? Faux wood is a wood composite overlaid on top of a steel garage door. You can choose between the natural wood grain, stains, and types like a real custom wood garage door without the hefty installation costs! Request a faux wood garage door from us today!

faux wood garage doors

Between Garage Doors? Fawley Overhead Door Can Help!

If you’re still deciding between options for new garage doors, start by turning to Fawley Overhead Door for your garage door installation in Portage, Kalamazoo, and the surrounding areas. We’ll walk you through each option and make the decision process a simple one for every homeowner.

There are plenty of perks to getting a new garage door, but the last thing you want to do is choose a type out of the blue. But how can you decide between wood, steel, and the other quality options on the market? Visit our Garage Doors page for more information about our family-owned and operated company, and our Gallery for some garage door style inspo!
Contact us today and get in touch with our team!

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top